Guides
Choosing a kit to suit your modelling ability
Model kit contents sometimes cross-over by containing more than
one medium, but on the whole you'll be able to identify the various
types by the following descriptions...
Injection
Moulded
These are probably the most common type of model kit, with tanks,
cars, aircraft and ships being popular subjects. Usually produced
in a hard polystyrene plastic which can be joined by a number of
glues, the nature of these kits is such that they are built from
components which have to be sub-assembled before final assembly
and complexity can range from a few easy to assemble parts to containing
dozens of components requiring expert modelling knowledge.
Most
injection moulded kit components align together using a system of
locating pins and holes or slots and tabs. Accuracy of these often
determines whether the kit’s a good one or not, but badly located
parts don’t always mean disaster, as corrections by the modelmaker
can often be made. Components are generally identified by a series
of numbers or letters, or both, and instruction sheets, leaflets
or booklets provide written or diagrammatic instructions of the
assembly sequence. Instructions vary enormously in their quality
and can cause problems for the novice, although a trial assembly
of parts without the use of glue will often answer queries that
are not clear.
Producing
injection mouldings unfortunately involves a very expensive series
of processes, meaning only large manufacturers produce the vast
majority of this type of kit. Much of the cost is generated by the
tools required to mould a kits components. Basically, molten plastic
is injected under pressure into a tool made from steel. This tool,
which will normally be constructed from several pieces, holds the
shape of the components. The manufacturing process, and the cost
of tooling, is why injection moulded kits are supplied as a series
of components on a framework, known as the sprue. This enables far
more components to be produced from one tool, helping to reduce
some of the costs. Whilst this saves money, it also means that each
component has a runner or feeder joining it to the sprue. These
indicate where plastic is fed to the components, and whilst a necessary
part of the process, they have caused problems for modellers in
the past. Size and positioning of runners is critical; too big and
they make it difficult to remove components from the sprue, too
small and components can become mis-shapen due to a lack of plastic
getting to the tool. Other problems with the process include flash,
sink marks, distortion, and parts that don't match up very well.
These are often caused by poor tooling, which comes back down to
costs. It's a case of the more money spent on tooling, the better
the quality of the kit. Manufacturers either have to sell more kits,
or increase prices to recover costs. It's a vicious circle that
can sometimes prove frustrating for modellers.
All
of these generalisations regarding the construction and manufacture
of injection moulded kits are due to there being no set standards
adopted by the manufacturers. Some provide location pins and some
don’t, some provide instructions with diagrams and some are just
written, so you can see that the modeller has to build up knowledge
over the years. A main advantage with injection moulded kits however
is the price, for despite the expensive tooling process, the number
of kits able to be produced means that retail costs are on average
around twenty pounds, but can vary from as little as three pounds
to as much as one hundred pounds or more, depending on the type
and it's complexity. Another advantage is their availability, because
they are very often available from general hobby shops, toy shops
and toy departments as well as model shops.
Vac
Formed
Unlike injection moulded kits, the components for this type of kit
are cut from a sheet of material which are then cleaned prior to
assembly. The tabs or pins that are used to locate injection moulded
parts are absent on vac formed kits, and so these have to be added
from scrap plastic.
The
vac formed kit is not really suited to the novice, but construction
skills are reasonably basic, and as such can be acquired fairly
quickly by modellers new to the medium. Prices can vary depending
on the production run and the complexity of the kit. Basic vac formed
mouldings are often supplemented by white metal castings and sometimes,
injection moulded plastic components. Their inclusion can result
in slightly higher pricing, due mainly to the costs involved in
producing these additional items, but on the whole they are similar
to those of injection moulded kits.
The
great thing about vac formed kits is the low costs involved due
to a relatively simple production process. Basically, the production
of vac formed kits is a matter of heating a sheet of thin plastic
which is then either drawn down onto a tool, or pushed into by the
tool. The plastic then takes the general form of the tool, but by
applying vacuum suction to the plastic via tiny drilled holes in
the tool, the sheet is pulled down over it to capture all of the
detail. The process can be very successful, but there are limitations.
The level of skill the tool maker or the person operating the vac
forming machine has determines how good the results are. Problems
stem from the thickness of plastic being used, and if the tool is
made incorrectly or the moulding isn’t pulled properly, it is possible
for the mouldings to have large radii in the corners, or lack sharp
detail. Other problems can occur, but skilful tool makers and machine
operators can usually work around them. One way to overcome large
radii on the mouldings, is to produce a female tool rather than
a male tool. A male tool reproduces the shape of the model but with
the plastic thickness removed from all surfaces, so that when the
plastic is pulled down over the tool, the resulting mouldings are
dimensionally correct. A female tool is the reverse of this, with
the plastic being pulled into a hollow tool. This has the advantage
of putting the sharp detail on the outside of the mouldings, but
producing the tool is a little harder. The tool is also produced
to the dimensions of the finished component; no allowance for material
thickness is needed.
This
type of kit is readily available from a number of manufacturers
and, because of the relatively low cost involved in producing this
type of kit, the process is open to 'cottage industry' manufacturers.
Production runs can be low, and there are many established moulding
companies that are able to accept vac forming jobs from small manufacturers,
thus reducing the need to invest in expensive machinery, and therefore
reducing overheads. It’s often these smaller manufacturers that
are able to produce kits of the more unusual subjects, subjects
that larger manufacturers wouldn’t normally consider due to the
relatively low interest and subsequent potential sales.
Resin
These kits often consist of very few components which are usually
easy to clean and can be glued with conventional plastic glue; they
require either super glue or an epoxy adhesive, both of which are
simple to use.
Resin
kits are, in my opinion, far simpler to construct compared to injection
moulded kits. The manufacturing process involved in the making of
resin kits usually means that there is a little less construction
work needed. Items that would be built up from a number of components
in an injection moulded kit can often be cast as a single piece
in resin. The resulting components often require just the moulding
'plug' to be cleaned up before assembly, the ‘plug’ being the additional
resin that is left at the point where the resin is poured into the
mould. Again, they are quite different to injection moulded kits,
requiring slightly different skills. Resin components are cast in
one of a variety of polyurethane resins that are available from
a number of manufacturers. A rubber mould is constructed of the
component into which the resin is poured; this can be a single or
multi-piece mould that is taken from a master model of the component.
Once the resin has cured (set), the component can be removed from
the mould and more resin added to make another component. The relatively
simple manufacturing process lends itself, in the same way as the
vac formed kits, to the ‘cottage industry’ manufacturer, and some
of these have perfected the process to such an extent that the models
produced are of a much higher quality than some other materials.
However the process does have limitations, and there are ways in
which the process can be used badly, yielding poor results. Due
to the costs of the resin and the moulds, plus the relatively low
production runs involved with resin kits, the prices of these kits
often tend to be a little more expensive than injection moulded
kits.
White
Metal
Apart from the obvious weight difference, the main difference
between a resin and a white metal kit is the casting; metal is cast
when hot whilst resin is cast when cold. As such the types of moulds
used are slightly different, being capable of withstanding the high
temperature of the molten metal.
White
metal is not only used for kits and miniatures, but for accessories
in other kits too, such as vac formed, resin, and vinyl. They aren’t
as common as some of the other types of kit mentioned above, but
there are a large number of kits that use white metal in them. When
cast correctly the detail that one can expect from a white metal
component is second to none, and as with resin components, these
can be cast in sizes that would normally be built up from several
pieces in an injection moulded kit.
When
cast properly, white metal kits only require a little work before
assembly, removing the runners and cleaning up any flaws that are
present on the castings. The tools used are in general the same
as those used on any other kit, including sandpaper, files, knives
and filler. White metal kits can be fixed together in a number of
ways. The easiest way for the beginner is probably super glue, which
gives an instant bond, and does not require any additional clamping
whilst the glue sets. Two-part epoxy glue can also be used, but
this does mean that there are occasions when components will need
to be held in place whilst the glue sets. The final method of fixing
components, and not really recommended for the inexperienced, is
soldering, where the components are soldered together. This requires
a little more skill, and a low temperature solder is best used,
otherwise there can be occasions when the heat of the soldering
iron will melt the white metal components!
Vinyl
Different to the type of kits you’re probably more used to building,
vinyl kits usually consist of just a few components and are very
simple to put together. In fact, they’re one of the simplest forms
of model you can build, and detailing quality is superb on most
available kits.
Construction
once again requires the same basic tools that you might use for
other types of models and the components can be glued together using
super glue. The majority of problems that people encounter when
building vinyl kits come from painting, but with correct preparation
and paints, excellent results can be achieved.
Vinyl
kits are manufactured by a simple process that effectively blows
vinyl into a female mould that has been made to the shape of the
components. The vinyl conforms to the shape of the mould, and when
removed, the exterior of the vinyl moulding reproduces the shape
of the inside of the mould exactly, leaving just a small amount
of excess to be removed. This process allows very complex shapes
to be reproduced in single pieces rather than a number of components
that then have to be glued together.
In
recent years, vinyl kits have become a lot more common and have,
to an extent, stepped in on kits that would have previously been
produced by vac form. As with vac formed kits, vinyl tends to cover
more specialised subjects, bringing modellers kits that would not
normally be injection moulded. However, one problem that still remains
with these kits is the price, which tends to be quite high, discouraging
some modellers from trying them out. If you can afford to try out
one of these kits, it’s well worth the experience.
|